Why splitting a business to avoid VAT can backfire badly

CREATED BY HELEN BEAUMONT Published: 26/11/2025 @ 09:00AM #splittingabusinesstoavoidVAT #VAT #HMRC #smallbusinesstax #UKaccounting #VATregistration

Splitting a business to avoid VAT may look clever, but it often isn't. HMRC can join entities together where links exist and challenge the arrangement. Consider contracts, commercial reality, and long-term costs before acting ...

Splitting a business, To avoid VAT costs high, Savings or stress?

Many owners toy with splitting their business to avoid VAT because it appears to shave off costs with minimal effort, but the surface savings can mask deeper legal and operational risks that are easy to underestimate.

The instinct is understandable!

When the VAT threshold looms and margins are thin, avoiding a charge feels like protecting value. Yet HMRC rules are designed to look through structures that exist mainly to sidestep tax, and the regulator's lens focuses on how the deal actually works, not just how it is described on paper.

The calculation often overlooks the power HMRC holds to treat closely connected entities as a single VAT registration when economic, financial, and organisational links align.

The word 'and' matters here; they need to evidence all three, but when they can, they may mandate a single registration going forward, eroding any short-term gain. That means duplicated admin, reissued invoices, strained client relationships, and possibly penalties or interest, none of which show up in the spreadsheet that justified the split.

The smarter approach is to anchor any structure in commercial reality first and tax consequences second, not the other way around. If two entities:

• genuinely negotiate separately,
• carry separate risk,
• invoice independently,
• and manage complaints and extras in their own right,

That aligns with reality and documentation, which is where accounting best practice lives.

If, however, the split is cosmetic while one party controls price, service and cash flow, the substance will trump the labels, and HMRC will likely press for a combined position.

The line between efficient planning and artificial fragmentation is drawn by contracts, conduct and cash. Contracts should mirror how the parties behave: who sets the price, who handles complaints, who gets paid, and who carries liability.

If the paperwork says one thing, but day-to-day processes say another, the weak link becomes a lever for challenge, and small business tax savings can evaporate quickly when reconciled against compliance costs and reputational damage.

The commercial upside of keeping activities focused is
real, but it must be defensible under scrutiny!

Marketing claims should reflect the legal reality, because language that implies bundled services when the model is actually split can invite questions that are tedious to answer. Clear invoicing, direct payment flows, and authentic separation of responsibilities build credibility, whereas vague promises and 'free' add-ons invite the kind of probing that few want when the VAT threshold is in sight.

A measured plan for VAT registration, paired with pricing that reflects market value and tax, often outperforms thin-margin contortions. It is easier to scale without awkward re-engineering later, which is the operational dividend people forget!

The practical test is simple and unforgiving: if the structure disappeared tomorrow, would the businesses still stand alone, with separate strategy, finance and operations, or would everything fold back into one de facto entity?If it is the latter, the supposed savings from splitting a business to avoid VAT may be illusory, and the eventual cost of correction could exceed the original outlay by a wide margin.

The safest course is deliberate design grounded in genuine commercial logic, transparent contracts, and consistent execution, supported by solid tax and legal advice that anticipates HMRC's perspective.

When the model is authentic, it always stands up.

Until next time ...

HELEN BEAUMONT
Join my mailing list! Click here and be one of the first to know when I publish a new blog post!

Share the blog love ...

Buffer Facebook Twitter Linkedin Pinterest WhatsApp #splittingabusinesstoavoidVAT #VAT #HMRC #smallbusinesstax #UKaccounting #VATregistration

About Helen Beaumont ...
Helen brings the personal tax planning experience of the top 20 tax companies to Essendon. Formerly of MacIntyre Hudson (with 45 offices nationwide), Helen worked at Chancery for more than 10 years before joining Essendon as the personal tax specialist. Tax Planning can make a considerable difference to your tax liability. Helen has specialist knowledge and experience in tax planning and uses every opportunity to minimise your tax bill is utilised. By analysing your investments, income, profit and expenditures, Helen will provide strategic tax planning expertise that could offer significant savings, whilst delivering clear, honest advice and guidance. When Helen is not at Essendon she spends time with her young son and likes going on long walks with the family dog.

More blog posts for you to enjoy ...
		New Year Nudge: Beat the self-assessment filing deadline without stress Here's the simple reality of the self-assessment filing deadline: it doesn't move, but your stress can. My blog post this week explains why filing early helps, what HMRC charges for delays, and how an online tax return can ke...
		HMRC Taking A Good Look At Savvy Online Sellers HMRC's new data sharing initiative, which aligns with the OECD's global objective to tackle tax evasion, has been met with mixed reactions from online sellers ......
		How HMRC Christmas tax rules trip up festive side hustlers HMRC Christmas tax rules often surprise side hustlers each December. Here's what counts, what doesn't, and when to register. Stay compliant and keep more of your Christmas earnings ......
		Do I need to file a self-assessment tax return? Unsure if you must file a self-assessment tax return? This guide explains who needs to file, what income triggers it, and how to register with HMRC. Get clear before the tax return deadline ......
		Salary sacrifice changes set to hit millions of UK employees Salary sacrifice changes will cap tax-free pension contributions at £2,000 from April 2029. Many employees and employers will face higher costs and new admin. Here's what's changing, who's affected, and how to prepare ......
		Nine ways to beat the Budget tax burden this year Here's my smart, simple guide to beat the Budget tax burden without drama. I'll cover pensions, ISAs, dividends, cash, IHT and more. Read this to prioritise your tax savings and plan ahead with calm planning ......
		Chancellor eyes pension salary sacrifice: a £5.1bn question Rumours in the media suggest the Chancellor may curb pension salary sacrifice in the Autumn Budget. Employers, employees, and HMRC see risks to take-home pay and saving habits. Here's what could really happen ......
		Why farmers need an inheritance tax transitional gifting rule now Older farmers face a cliff edge in April 2026. An inheritance tax transitional gifting rule could ease pressure and protect family businesses. Here's why it matters and what should happen next ......

Other bloggers you may like ...
		Serviced accommodation for contractors in Milton Keynes: a smarter base for work Posted by Emily Freeman on https://blog.shortstay-mk.co.uk If you want a calm base that simply works, serviced accommodation for contractors beats hotels and patchy Airbnbs. You get your own place, proper faci ...
		You've been made redundant? Let's separate you from the job Posted by Dave Cordle on https://blog.davecordle.co.uk If you've been made redundant, it can feel personal, but it isn't. The role has gone, not your strengths, experience or future. Let's reset the story ...
		Key payroll changes for 2026 every UK employer should plan for now Posted by Roger Eddowes on https://blog.essendonaccounts.co.uk Key payroll changes for 2026 are mainly about higher wage floors, tighter thresholds and better forward planning. My blog post today walks through wha ...
		What an Online PA actually does for busy professionals Posted by Sarah Hannaford on https://blog.sarahpasolutions.co.uk Wondering what an Online PA actually does day to day? They keep schedules, inboxes and documents under control, while handling research and process-he ...