Trusts Did Not Benefit Family in £442k Inheritance Tax Case

CREATED BY HELEN BEAUMONT Published: 14/05/2025 @ 09:00AM #InheritanceTax #EstatePlanning #Trusts #TaxLaw #TaxPlanning

The recent case of Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC has significant implications for Inheritance Tax (IHT) legislation, particularly regarding trusts. The tribunal examined whether funds in two trusts qualified for exemption from IHT, ultimately concluding that they did not benefit the family as intended ...

The 'Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC' case serves as an essential teaching moment in the realm of inheritance tax and trust law

The complexities surrounding inheritance tax can often feel daunting, especially when cases revolve around the intricate nature of trusts and the stipulations of relevant legislation. A recent tribunal ruling, 'Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC [2025] UKFTT 00458 (TC)', has once again highlighted just how convoluted these matters can become.

In this particular case, the late Mohammed Chugtai's estate was scrutinised, leading to a disagreement between HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and his daughter and executrix, Afsha Chugtai, over potential inheritance tax liabilities.

At the heart of the matter was the interpretation of Section 102 of the Finance Act 1986!

This pertains to gifts with a reservation of benefit. While gifts made more than seven years before death are generally exempt from Inheritance Tax, this exemption does not apply if the donor continues to enjoy the property or retains some benefit from it. This legislation was key to HMRC's argument that the trusts, designed to reduce Mr. Chugtai's chargeable estate by £442,239, were invalid due to a retained benefit.

In a rather commendable move, the tribunal judges were eager to commend the legal representatives for their clear submissions. The legal battle underscored not just the intricacies of Inheritance Tax, but also the importance of how such cases are presented. For those seeking to challenge HMRC's findings, it highlights the necessity of presenting a robust case - complete with personal testimony and reliable evidence.

As it relates to the case, Mr. Chugtai had established two discretionary ‘interest in possession trusts’ in February 2000, aimed at benefiting his children. While the trusts were structured to exclude the deceased from benefiting from their assets, he returned to the Caversham property to care for a child with mental health issues, occupying the property without any evidence of paying rent.

In the eyes of HMRC, this was a clear indicator of
a reservation of benefit!

The agency contended that the beneficiary status of Mr. Chugtai's children could not take effect until it was demonstrated that they had genuinely assumed enjoyment and control of the trust property - criteria that were evidently not met based on the details provided.

The first point of contention arose from the assertion that the three beneficiaries had not assumed bona fide enjoyment of the trust property before the 26th February 2010. Alongside this, there were significant questions surrounding whether Mr. Chugtai was excluded from any benefit from the assets in the period leading up to his demise in 2017.

The tribunal was left with a comprehensive body of evidence that suggested the opposite - that Mr. Chugtai not only continued using the property, but had also employed the bank account associated with the trust for personal transactions, a scenario which undermined the very intention behind the setting up of the trusts.

The judges were unambiguous in their conclusion: “It is clear to us that the properties were not enjoyed to the exclusion or virtually the entire exclusion of the deceased.”

Counsel for the appellant proposed that Mr. Chugtai's motives for using the property were purely to care for his daughter, therefore contending that this did not constitute “enjoyment” in a conventional sense. However, the judges found this argument unsatisfactory.

They noted that the deceased not only occupied the property, but also used it for business purposes, along with receiving rent from the shop attached to the house. By continuing to manage the outcomes associated with the trust assets, Mr. Chugtai reserved benefits that blighted the estate planning efforts intended by the trust’s creation.

The tribunal also highlighted the means by which HMRC's arguments could have been countered effectively. A more suitable arrangement might have involved Mr. Chugtai paying full market rent for the property, which would have clarified the delineation of benefits between him and the beneficiaries. Such an approach would have reinforced the legitimacy of the trusts and potentially exempted the estate from inheritance tax.

The ruling serves as a crucial reminder for families
engaged in estate planning!

It conveys that without proper adherence to the rules governing trusts and the prudent establishment of circumstances that genuinely reflect the intent to benefit beneficiaries exclusively, the pursuit of tax advantages could have the opposite effect.

The 'Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC' case serves as an essential teaching moment in the realm of inheritance tax and trust law. Family estate planning can lead to unintended consequences if the intricacies of legal stipulations are not fully grasped and adhered to.

As the landscape of inheritance tax continues to evolve, this case stands as a stark reminder of the necessity for transparency and compliance when structuring trusts aimed at minimising tax liabilities. Families considering similar arrangements must remain vigilant - and perhaps seek expert legal advice to ensure they are navigating the intricate waters of inheritance tax successfully.

After all, inadequate preparation in such matters can result in significant financial repercussions.

Until next time ...

HELEN BEAUMONT
Join my mailing list! Click here and be one of the first to know when I publish a new blog post!

Share the blog love ...

Buffer Facebook Twitter Linkedin Pinterest WhatsApp #InheritanceTax #EstatePlanning #Trusts #TaxLaw #TaxPlanning

About Helen Beaumont ...
Helen brings the personal tax planning experience of the top 20 tax companies to Essendon. Formerly of MacIntyre Hudson (with 45 offices nationwide), Helen worked at Chancery for more than 10 years before joining Essendon as the personal tax specialist. Tax Planning can make a considerable difference to your tax liability. Helen has specialist knowledge and experience in tax planning and uses every opportunity to minimise your tax bill is utilised. By analysing your investments, income, profit and expenditures, Helen will provide strategic tax planning expertise that could offer significant savings, whilst delivering clear, honest advice and guidance. When Helen is not at Essendon she spends time with her young son and likes going on long walks with the family dog.

More blog posts for you to enjoy ...
		Welcome to the summer of VAT complexity and 5% surprises This summer's VAT complexity is not just about cheaper tickets and meals. It also brings fresh admin, tricky boundaries, and significant VAT compliance work for businesses. A small saving for families, perhaps, but a big exer...
		Why the middle-income trap matters in the salary sacrifice cap The salary sacrifice cap sounds as though it is aimed at high earners, but the detail creates a middle-income trap for everyday savers and SMEs. Below £2,000, the system still works well; above that, NI costs, payroll pressur...
		Final P11D deadline for HMRC expenses and Benefits in Kind filing The P11D deadline for HMRC expenses remains important this year, but bigger changes are coming soon. Employers using the old system should file on time, while others should start preparing for payroll reporting of Benefits in...
		Tax return changes put extra pressure on company directors Tax return changes are introducing a new admin for company directors, particularly regarding shareholdings and close companies. The rules do not force everyone into self-assessment, but they do make existing returns more deta...
		Employers' National Insurance increase and the squeeze on business budgets The Employers' National Insurance increase is making payroll more expensive, and that ripples through hiring, wages and investment. Businesses are feeling the strain, especially where margins are thin. It is a simple change w...
		HMRC Taking A Good Look At Savvy Online Sellers HMRC's new data sharing initiative, which aligns with the OECD's global objective to tackle tax evasion, has been met with mixed reactions from online sellers ......
		Probate: what documents do executors need to get started? What documents do executors need? In short, the papers that prove identity, assets, liabilities and family links matter most. Good records make probate application documents easier to prepare, reduce delays and help executors...
		Millions of pensioners face tax on winter fuel payments as rules change Millions of pensioners will face tax on winter fuel payments if their income surpasses the new threshold. Some will have taxes deducted through PAYE, while others will need to handle it via a tax return. Although it appears s...

Other bloggers you may like ...
		Why a complete marketing channel beats blog writing alone Posted by Steffi Lewis on https://www.sblogit.com Many businesses understand the value of blogging. They know that fresh content can help improve visibility, demonstrate expertise and give potential c ...
		How to be happy retiring from your consultancy, without losing yourself Posted by Jacky Sherman on https://www.jackysherman.com What makes a happy retirement when you've been in consultancy for years? It's less about stopping work and more about designing your identity, boundar ...
		Where corporate visitors stay in Milton Keynes for space, privacy and easy access Posted by Emily Freeman on https://blog.shortstay-mk.co.uk Wondering where corporate visitors stay in Milton Keynes? You'll see why many teams pick serviced accommodation from Short Stay : MK over hotels and A ...
		How a growth mindset can help your career Posted by Dave Cordle on https://blog.davecordle.co.uk If you want to advance your career, your skills and experience certainly matter. However, the way you approach challenges, setbacks, and opportunities ...