Trusts Did Not Benefit Family in £442k Inheritance Tax Case
The recent case of Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC has significant implications for Inheritance Tax (IHT) legislation, particularly regarding trusts. The tribunal examined whether funds in two trusts qualified for exemption from IHT, ultimately concluding that they did not benefit the family as intended ... The 'Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC' case serves as an essential teaching moment in the realm of inheritance tax and trust law The complexities surrounding inheritance tax can often feel daunting, especially when cases revolve around the intricate nature of trusts and the stipulations of relevant legislation. A recent tribunal ruling, 'Afsha Chugtai vs HMRC [2025] UKFTT 00458 (TC)', has once again highlighted just how convoluted these matters can become. In this particular case, the late Mohammed Chugtai's estate was scrutinised, leading to a disagreement between HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and his daughter and executrix, Afsha Chugtai, over potential inheritance tax liabilities. At the heart of the matter was the interpretation of Section 102 of the Finance Act 1986!This pertains to gifts with a reservation of benefit. While gifts made more than seven years before death are generally exempt from Inheritance Tax, this exemption does not apply if the donor continues to enjoy the property or retains some benefit from it. This legislation was key to HMRC's argument that the trusts, designed to reduce Mr. Chugtai's chargeable estate by £442,239, were invalid due to a retained benefit. In a rather commendable move, the tribunal judges were eager to commend the legal representatives for their clear submissions. The legal battle underscored not just the intricacies of Inheritance Tax, but also the importance of how such cases are presented. For those seeking to challenge HMRC's findings, it highlights the necessity of presenting a robust case - complete with personal testimony and reliable evidence. As it relates to the case, Mr. Chugtai had established two discretionary ‘interest in possession trusts’ in February 2000, aimed at benefiting his children. While the trusts were structured to exclude the deceased from benefiting from their assets, he returned to the Caversham property to care for a child with mental health issues, occupying the property without any evidence of paying rent. In the eyes of HMRC, this was a clear indicator of | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Would you like to know more? |
If anything I've written in my blog post resonates with you and you'd like to discover more of my thoughts about this case or ensuring you maximise the benefits from a trust correctly, then do feel free to call me on 01908 774323 and let's see how I can help you. |
Share the blog love ... | |||||||||||||||||||||||
#InheritanceTax #EstatePlanning #Trusts #TaxLaw #TaxPlanning |
About Helen Beaumont ... | ||
|
More blog posts for you to enjoy ... | ||
![]() | A pension tax raid would put the NHS in danger A pension tax raid risks driving GPs to retire early and undermining new neighbourhood care plans. It could also destabilise NHS funding and deepen workforce gaps. Clarity on tax reforms is urgently needed, especially with th... | |
![]() | HMRC launches real-time HICBC payment for smoother PAYE HMRC's real-time HICBC payment lets employees settle the charge through PAYE. It's quick, accurate and avoids self-assessment for many. It's a practical win for households receiving child benefit ...... | |
![]() | Are directors' loans a good cash flow strategy or just another tax trap? Here's a straight-talking take on directors' loans. They can ease cash flow or invite HMRC scrutiny. Used with discipline, they work; misused, they hurt ...... | |
![]() | Salary or Dividends: Optimising Income for Directors Directors of limited companies must make informed decisions about their remuneration strategies. Optimising income for directors involves balancing salaries and dividends while considering significant changes to tax legislati... | |
![]() | Should Directors Use Salary Sacrifice To Reduce Income Tax And National Insurance? Wondering if salary sacrifice to reduce tax is worth it? You can cut NI, boost pension contributions, and keep payroll efficient. Here's how it works for directors ...... | |
![]() | UK Unveils Amnesty For Covid Loan Debtors: Your Last Clean-Slate Chance Here's what the UK's amnesty for Covid loan debtors means for you. Pay back what you shouldn't have taken, no questions asked. Miss it, and expect tougher enforcement soon ...... | |
![]() | Understanding The 10-Year Charge On Trusts Without The Headaches The 10-Year charge on trusts can be a confusing subject for many, so here's a clear, friendly guide in blog post form. Learn what it is, how it's calculated, and what you need to do. Stay compliant and avoid surprises ...... | |
![]() | HMRC Pension Relief Crackdown: What Higher-Rate Taxpayers Need To Know The HMRC pension relief crackdown means stricter evidence rules, no phone claims, and more checks. If you're a higher-rate taxpayer, you'll need accurate figures and documents. Get your pension contributions data ready to cla... | |
Other bloggers you may like ... | ||
![]() | Blogging: Why You're Not Doing It And How sBlogIt! Can Do It For You Instead Posted by Steffi Lewis on https://www.sblogit.com Blogging is a missed opportunity for many small business owners. You may worry you lack the time or expertise to do it effectively. With sBlogIt!, the ... | |
![]() | Building Your Bookkeeping Business Posted by Alison Mead on https://blog.siliconbullet.com The usual question I see asked in bookkeeping groups and forums is, where can I find customers, or how can I get experience now that I have passed my ... | |
![]() | How the HMRC R&D tax relief tool can streamline claims Posted by Roger Eddowes on https://blog.essendonaccounts.co.uk Curious about the HMRC R&D tax relief tool? Here's how it clarifies eligibility, reduces risk, and supports better claims. It's a pragmatic boost for ... | |
![]() | Why serviced accommodation in Milton Keynes beats traditional hotel stays Posted by Emily Freeman on https://blog.shortstay-mk.co.uk Here's why serviced accommodation in Milton Keynes is a smarter choice than a hotel. Expect more space, better Wi‑Fi, and the freedom to live on your ... | |















